Understanding CSA Scores and Their Impact on Fleets

For fleet managers and commercial truck drivers, maintaining a good CSA (Compliance, Safety, Accountability) score is crucial. The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) uses CSA scores to assess the safety performance of commercial motor vehicle (CMV) carriers and drivers. A poor score can lead to fines, audits, higher insurance rates, and even suspension of operating authority.

This guide will break down how CSA scores work, the factors affecting them, and actionable steps to improve them while keeping your fleet compliant with FMCSA regulations.

What is a CSA Score?

A CSA score is a safety measurement system used by the FMCSA to evaluate motor carriers based on safety-related data. The FMCSA’s Safety Measurement System (SMS) analyzes a carrier’s performance in seven Behavior Analysis and Safety Improvement Categories (BASICs):

• Unsafe Driving – Speeding, reckless driving, distracted driving, improper lane changes.
• Crash Indicator – History of crashes, severity, and frequency.
• Hours-of-Service (HOS) Compliance – Violations related to driver logbooks, rest breaks, and fatigue management.
• Vehicle Maintenance – Faulty brakes, lights, tires, and overall vehicle condition.
• Controlled Substances and Alcohol – Drug and alcohol violations.
• Hazardous Materials Compliance – Proper labeling, packaging, and handling of hazardous materials.
• Driver Fitness – Valid commercial driver’s license (CDL), medical certifications, and training records.

A lower CSA score indicates better compliance, reducing the risk of FMCSA interventions, audits, and penalties.

How to Improve Your CSA Score

1. Reduce Unsafe Driving Violations

Unsafe driving is one of the biggest contributors to poor CSA scores. To improve:

✅ Train drivers on defensive driving techniques.
✅ Implement Electronic Logging Devices (ELDs) to monitor driving behavior.
✅ Use fleet telematics systems to track real-time driver behavior and issue alerts for speeding or harsh braking.
✅ Encourage a zero-tolerance policy for reckless driving.

2. Improve Hours-of-Service (HOS) Compliance

HOS violations can severely impact your CSA score and lead to FMCSA penalties. To stay compliant:

✅ Use ELDs to automate HOS tracking and prevent logbook falsifications.
✅ Educate drivers on HOS regulations, rest periods, and penalties for violations.
✅ Schedule routes and loads efficiently to avoid pressure on drivers to exceed hours.

3. Enhance Vehicle Maintenance Practices

Regular vehicle maintenance reduces the risk of roadside inspections, violations, and accidents.

✅ Implement a preventive maintenance program using fleet maintenance software.
✅ Conduct daily pre-trip and post-trip inspections to check brakes, tires, lights, and fluid levels.
✅ Address reported defects immediately to avoid recurring violations.

Learn more about preventive maintenance best practices in our guide: Preventive Maintenance for Fleets.

4. Improve Crash Indicator Performance

Even if a crash isn’t your fault, it affects your CSA score. Steps to reduce accidents:

✅ Enforce defensive driving training for all fleet drivers.
✅ Use dash cams to document incidents and contest false claims.
✅ Implement a post-accident protocol to ensure proper reporting and review of incidents.

5. Ensure Compliance with Drug and Alcohol Testing

Substance-related violations can cripple your CSA score. Prevent them by:

✅ Enforcing random drug and alcohol testing in compliance with FMCSA’s Drug & Alcohol Clearinghouse.
✅ Providing substance abuse training for fleet managers and drivers.
✅ Keeping records of all test results and disciplinary actions for compliance checks.

Learn more about FMCSA compliance requirements in our guide: Understanding DOT Compliance for Small Fleets.

6. Optimize Hazardous Materials (HAZMAT) Compliance

For fleets transporting hazardous materials, maintaining compliance is critical.

✅ Train drivers on hazmat safety regulations and proper handling procedures.
✅ Ensure accurate labeling, placarding, and documentation to avoid penalties.
✅ Regularly inspect hazardous materials cargo to prevent spills, leaks, or compliance issues.

7. Improve Driver Fitness and Licensing Compliance

A poor Driver Fitness score indicates issues with CDL validity, medical certifications, and qualifications.

✅ Keep track of driver license renewals and medical exams using fleet management software.
✅ Conduct routine training and assessments to ensure compliance with FMCSA standards.
✅ Remove non-compliant drivers from routes until they meet fitness requirements.

Best Practices for Maintaining a Good CSA Score

✅ Regularly Check Your CSA Score

Use the FMCSA Safety Measurement System (SMS) Portal to monitor your fleet’s score.

✅ Contest Incorrect Violations

If a violation is unfair, challenge it via the FMCSA’s DataQs system.

✅ Invest in Fleet Safety Technology

Use advanced telematics, AI dashcams, and real-time monitoring to reduce violations.

✅ Educate Your Team

Conduct ongoing driver training programs to reinforce safety policies.

✅ Partner with a Compliance Expert

Work with compliance consultants to stay ahead of FMCSA rule changes.

FAQs About CSA Scores

How often is my CSA score updated?

CSA scores are updated once a month, based on roadside inspections, crash reports, and investigations.

What is a good CSA score?

Each BASIC category has a threshold score, with lower scores being better. A score above the intervention threshold could lead to FMCSA scrutiny.

Can I remove violations from my CSA score?

Yes, through the FMCSA’s DataQs system, you can dispute inaccurate violations and request corrections.

How long do violations stay on my CSA record?

Most violations stay on record for 24 months, but severe violations may impact your score longer.

Final Thoughts: Take Control of Your CSA Score

A poor CSA score can result in higher insurance costs, DOT interventions, and lost business opportunities. By proactively addressing key BASIC categories, implementing safety technologies, and staying compliant with FMCSA regulations, you can improve your CSA score and maintain a strong safety record.

Start improving your CSA score today by prioritizing safety, compliance, and proactive fleet management!

For fleets looking to automate compliance tracking, consider using Simply Fleet’s fleet maintenance software to monitor violations, track maintenance schedules, and ensure real-time compliance.

‍